Nobody enjoys being the bad guy…well, most people anyway. Yet, as you step into leadership roles, it is easy to overlook a fundamental truth: eventually, you are going to make a decision that upsets someone.
I once had a staff member come to me expressing a strong desire to move into a leadership position. In all honesty, I saw their potential and believed they could be a great leader, just not yet. Unfortunately, they didn't see it that way. They felt ready, under appreciated, and my decision to hold them back stung. The irony was that their behaviour over the rest of the summer proved just how unprepared they truly were. Unfortunately, they never saw it. Instead, they turned their frustration on me, speaking negatively about my leadership and, likely to this day, blaming me for their struggles that summer and beyond.
Looking back, perhaps there were ways I could have handled it better, but experiences like this carry two vital lessons for anyone in charge.
First, your job is to protect the big picture. That young staff member wasn't ready to lead, and the team they would have supervised didn't deserve to bear the brunt of their growing pains. When you build, or, as I prefer to say, cultivate a team, you have to look beyond who simply checks the boxes on paper. You have to consider who will inspire others, who will build genuine connections, and how every piece fits together for the health of the whole group.
Second, being a good leader means accepting that you have to disappoint people. Nobody likes delivering bad news, and it is completely natural to want to be liked. However, if you feel like everyone on your team is constantly happy with you, you are likely avoiding hard decisions just to keep the peace. At the end of the day, you aren't their friend; you are their boss. Setting people up for long-term success rarely means telling them what they want to hear. It means telling them what they need to hear…even when that message is "not yet," or that their time with your organization has come to an end. I have been on the receiving end of both, and have only learned from it.
Disappointment, failure, and honest feedback are how we grow. If we want to build the next generation of leaders, we have to hold the line and model the accountability we expect from them. It might feel awful in the moment, and people might walk away upset, but the team, and them, will be stronger for it.
Because at the end of the day, camp is for the campers, not for your ego.